Roam vs Loom



If Loom’s founder thinks he shouldn’t have to pay for Loom, why should you?

What Loom Is

Loom launched in 2015 as a quick async video tool — record your screen, talk, send a link. It grew into the dominant tool in the async video category. In October 2023, Atlassian acquired Loom for $975 million. All three original founders have since departed.

Loom today is an async screen recorder inside the Atlassian product family. The recording experience is fast and sharing is straightforward. Since the acquisition, billing and user management have migrated to Atlassian Administration, pricing has increased significantly, and reliability issues have been reported across review platforms.

The Founders

Howard Lerman previously built Yext, which IPO’d on the NYSE in 2017 at over $2 billion. He is fully focused on Roam and actively leads the product day to day.

Loom’s co-founders — Joe Thomas, Vinay Hiremath, and Shahed Khan — have all left following the Atlassian acquisition. Vinay Hiremath posted a $198 Loom invoice in November 2025 with the caption: “It really should be illegal that I have to pay for @loom.”

What They Have in Common

Both Roam Magicast and Loom record screens, support webcam overlay and background blur, auto-generate transcripts, and share via link. Both offer unlimited recordings on paid plans.

Since the Atlassian Acquisition

1. Loom raised prices dramatically in February 2026.

Atlassian eliminated the Creator Lite (free viewer) seat, requiring all workspace members to be billed as full paid users. For a 100-person team where only 10 people record videos: previously ~$2,160/year for 10 seats; now ~$21,600/year for all 100. Annual plans moved to fixed user tiers — 55 users pays for the 100-seat tier. AI features (summaries, chapters, filler word removal, transcript editing) require the Business + AI plan at $20–$24/user/month, on top of the base $15/user/month Business plan.

Roam is $19.50/seat/month, monthly billing, all nine products included.

2. Reliability issues have increased.

Since the Atlassian migration, users across G2, Trustpilot, and Reddit have reported lag, audio sync problems, failed uploads, and login issues.

3. Commenting now requires an Atlassian account.

Viewing or leaving comments on a Loom video requires the viewer to be logged into an Atlassian account. Viewers without one can’t see or interact with comments.

4. Viewer analytics are limited to logged-in users.

View counts are available on all plans, but named viewer identity, percentage watched, and replay data are only visible if the viewer has a Loom account and is signed in. External stakeholders appear as anonymous.

Roam identifies every viewer by name — everyone in a Roam workspace is already logged in.

5. Loom requires a browser extension or desktop app.

Roam Magicast is built into the Roam app — no separate install. Loom requires a browser extension or desktop app download.

6. Loom is one product. Roam is nine.

Loom is a screen recorder. Roam includes Magicast (screen recorder) plus Virtual Office Map, Drop-In Meetings, Theater (up to 3,000), Lobby (meeting scheduler), AInbox (AI-native chat), Magic Minutes (AI note-taker, no bot), On-It (AI assistant), and On-Air (virtual events). All at $19.50/seat/month.

Screen Recorder Features

FeatureRoam MagicastLoom
Screen recording
Record select area
Webcam overlay
Background blur
Mac + Windows
No install required✅ Embedded in Roam app❌ Extension or desktop app required
No browser extension❌ Extension is primary interface
Recording length100 min5 min free / unlimited paid
Video storageUnlimited25 videos free / unlimited paid
Workspace membersUnlimited50 free / unlimited paid
Auto transcript✅ Interactive, clickable✅ Paid plans
Transcript search✅ Paid
AI summaries / chapters🔜 Coming soon✅ Business + AI plan
($20/mo add-on)
Basic trim
Advanced editing⚠️ AI plan only
Comments🔜 Roadmap⚠️ Requires Atlassian account
View count✅ All plans
Named viewer identity✅ Always⚠️ Logged-in users only
% watched per viewer⚠️ Logged-in users only
Replay count per viewer⚠️ Aggregate only
Password-protected links✅ Business+ plan
Shareable links

Platform Breadth

ProductRoam MagicastLoom
Virtual Office✅ Virtual Office Map
Video Conferencing✅ Drop-In Meetings❌ Async only
Virtual All Hands✅ Theater (up to 3,000)
Meeting Scheduler✅ Lobby
Enterprise Chat✅ AInbox (AI-native)⚠️ Video comments only
AI Note Taker✅ Magic Minutes (no bot)⚠️ Meeting recap on AI plan only
Screen Recorder✅ Magicast✅ Core product
AI Assistant✅ On-It
Virtual Events✅ On-Air

Pricing

Roam MagicastLoom
Entry price$19.50/seat/mo — all 9 products$15/user/mo annual; AI features $20/mo
BillingMonthly or annualAnnual required
Viewer seatsUnlimited, includedEliminated Feb 2026 — all users now billed
AI featuresIncludedSeparate $20/mo tier
Free tierTrial5 min/video, 25 videos
Company statusIndependent, founder-ledAcquired by Atlassian; all founders departed
ARR$3M, +148% in 2025Part of Atlassian

Who Chooses Roam

Teams that need more than async video. Teams reassessing Loom costs after the February 2026 pricing changes. Teams that want named viewer analytics. Teams that want meetings, scheduling, chat, and a note-taker in one product at one price.

Who Chooses Loom

Teams deep in the Atlassian stack (Jira, Confluence) where native integrations matter. Teams that need only async video. Teams that need transcript-based video editing available today.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why did Loom’s pricing increase?

Atlassian eliminated the free viewer (Creator Lite) seat in February 2026, billing all workspace members at the full paid rate. Annual plans moved to fixed user tiers, so smaller teams pay for the next tier up.

Do Loom’s original founders still work there?

No. Joe Thomas, Vinay Hiremath, and Shahed Khan all left after the acquisition. Hiremath publicly posted his own Loom bill calling it unjustifiable.

Can external viewers comment on Loom videos?

No. Comments require an Atlassian account and active login. Viewers without accounts cannot see or leave comments.

Does Roam Magicast replace Loom?

For most team use cases, yes. Magicast covers screen recording, webcam, background blur, transcripts, and shareable links, with viewer analytics Loom doesn’t match. Advanced AI video editing and transcript-based editing are on Roam’s roadmap.

Is Roam cheaper than Loom?

$19.50/seat/month for all nine Roam products vs. $15–$20/user/month for Loom’s screen recorder alone — before accounting for Zoom, Calendly, and Slack on top.

Ready to Grow Your Business?

Demo
Book Demo
Live Demo with
Free Trial